top of page

How to work out what you really keep from a Whatnot card sale

Greedy TCG
Nov 9
2 min read

A sale price is not what lands in your account. If you sell trading cards on a live-show marketplace, the number that matters is what is left after fees, shipping and the cost of the card itself. Here is a simple way to check it before you go live.

Step 1: Start with the final sale price. In a live auction this is the winning bid, not your starting bid. Many cards sell well above or well below where the show opened, so judge a show by its closing prices, not its opening ones.

Step 2: Subtract the platform fees. The marketplace takes a commission on the sale and the payment processor takes its own cut. Both rates can change, so read the current seller fee page before you do your math instead of trusting an old post. If you want a walkthrough of the whole process, there is a free training on how to sell on Whatnot that covers setup, fees and your first shows.

Step 3: Subtract shipping and supplies. A single card in a top loader and a bubble mailer costs far less to send than a graded slab in a box, but every parcel still has a cost: postage, the sleeve, the mailer, the label. Add them up per order, and count the time it takes you to pack.

Step 4: Subtract what the card cost you. This is the step most new sellers skip. If you bought a card at a card show or pulled it from a pack, write down the price or an honest estimate, so you can see real margin and not just revenue.

Step 5: Check the card against recent sales. Before you list, look up what the same card, in the same condition, sold for in the last few weeks. Prices for popular Pokémon cards move with new set releases, tournament results and hype, so a number from three months ago can be wrong today.

A worked example with round numbers: a card sells for $40. Say the combined fees come to about $5, shipping and supplies about $1.50, and the card cost you $22. What is left is about $11.50. Change any one of those and the answer moves, which is why it pays to run the numbers on each card rather than guess.

Habits that help: keep a simple sheet with one row per sale, with columns for sale price, fees, shipping, cost and what you kept. Review it monthly. You will quickly see which kinds of cards earn their place in your shows and which ones only look busy.

If you want a quick way to check a card price before you list it, the free tools from Greedy TCG include a Pokémon card price checker and a PSA grading calculator.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page